What's the difference between exclusive and shared leads?
It comes down to how many contractors get the same homeowner. An exclusive lead is sent to one contractor. A shared lead is sent to several, and they all call.
| Shared leads | Exclusive leads | |
|---|---|---|
| How many crews get the homeowner | Several | One |
| Price per lead | Usually lower | Usually higher |
| What wins the job | Speed and price, most of the time | Your pitch, your work, your follow-up |
| Your first call | A race | A conversation |
| Room to sell a better system | Small. The homeowner is comparing numbers | Big. Nobody is undercutting you mid-call |
| Best for | Crews with someone answering leads instantly, all day | Crews who want to sell quality and close on value |
Shared lead platforms say this openly. Angi's pro help center, for example, says some of its lead types go to up to four pros.
What does a shared lead really cost?
More than the sticker price, because you don't win most of them. If a shared lead is cheaper but you close far fewer of them, your cost per job can end up higher than with an exclusive lead.
The way to know is to track cost per job won:
- Add up what you spent on leads from one source in a month.
- Count the jobs you closed from that source.
- Divide. That's your real cost per job.
Run the same math for every source. The lead value calculator shows how much one lead is worth to you at your close rate and average job.
Why do shared leads hurt coating crews in particular?
Because the cheap version of a coating looks a lot like the good one on day one. A kit-style single coat and a ground, repaired, full broadcast system both look shiny in a photo. When a homeowner gets four quotes, they can't see the difference, so they pick on price.
That pushes everyone to cut prep: less grinding, no crack repair, thinner coats. The floors fail, and the homeowner decides coatings don't work. Shared leads don't just cost you jobs. They train customers to buy the wrong floor.
Get exclusive epoxy leads
Every lead goes to you and nobody else. Guaranteed.
When do shared leads make sense?
Shared leads can work. They're a fair choice when:
- You have someone who calls every lead within minutes, every time
- You're new and need volume while you build reviews and photos
- Your price is already low and you're fine competing on it
- You're testing a new area and want cheap data
If that's you, shared leads aren't a mistake. Just track cost per job won so you know what they really cost.
When are exclusive leads worth it?
When your close rate goes up enough to cover the higher price per lead. Track it and you'll know. Exclusive leads fit if:
- You do proper prep and want to get paid for it
- You sell on quality and options, not the lowest number
- You can't sit by the phone all day to win a race
- You want every homeowner you pay for to be yours
That's what Epoxy Meta does. We run the advertising that finds homeowners in your area who want a floor coated. Each lead goes to one contractor only. Guaranteed. Cost depends on your area and the jobs you want, and we go over it on a quick call.
How do you check if a lead is really exclusive?
Ask the seller straight: "Is this lead sent to anyone else, ever?" Then ask if they guarantee it. A clear yes with a guarantee is what you want. Anything vague, like "limited" or "semi-exclusive," usually means shared.
Then watch the homeowner. If they tell you on the first call that three other companies already called, you have your answer.
For platform-by-platform details, see the Angi and HomeAdvisor alternative and Thumbtack alternative pages.
Questions
Are exclusive leads always better?
No. They cost more per lead. They're better when you close enough more of them to come out ahead on cost per job. Track both and let the numbers decide.
What's a semi-exclusive lead?
Usually a lead shared with a small number of contractors. Ask exactly how many. If the answer isn't one, it's shared.
Are Epoxy Meta leads exclusive?
Yes. Every lead goes to one contractor only. We guarantee it's never sent to anyone else.
How do I compare a cheap shared lead to an exclusive one?
Compare cost per job won, not cost per lead. Track spend and closed jobs for each source for at least a few weeks.
Do exclusive leads close themselves?
No. You still have to call fast, see the floor and give a clear quote. The follow-up script helps.